|
|
|
|
|
|
HomeBooksHumorDilbertWhat Would Wally Do?: A Dilbert Treasury (Dilbert Books (Paperback Andrews McMeel)) |
|
|  |
| Customer Reviews: | | Average Customer Review:
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
 This is a poor collection Dec 18, 2008
If you like Dilbert books don't buy this product. This is a collection of cartoons that only include Wally. Wally is great, but this collection removes any strip that doesn't have him in it. You don't get the entire story line. If there's no perspective you can't always tell why a strip is funny. Dilbert strips are generally written with a week long story line. If you only get a couple from the middle, you can't tell what is going on.
 Laziness is pretty funny Dec 25, 2007
Great book, very funny. Wally is my favorite Dilbert character. He's like Randy Moss (of the Raiders, not the one today) but with much less talent for his career. I enjoyed this one as much as any Dilbert book.
3 of 3 found the following review helpful:
 Disappointing - Scott Adams should be mad Jul 06, 2007
Dilbert is a great comic strip, and it's a fine idea to assemble a bunch of funny strips about Wally. I don't even mind that it's all recycled material.
But it's an insult to the reader to assemble the strips so badly. If there are two strips from the same sequence, why separate them by several pages? I'm taking this one back - it doesn't add anything new and it's edited badly.
2 of 2 found the following review helpful:
 A book about Wally or by Wally? Jun 27, 2007
I can't decide if the poor editing in this book is intended to be part of the humor or not. The "Wally Version 1.0" back story was entertaining and, as always, there were some laugh-out-loud strips in this book.
Unfortunately though, it seems that the publisher assigned some interns to pull out all the Dilbert strips they could find where Wally supplies the punch line and then put them in the book in no particular order. At first, it appears that the strips are being presented in the order they were written or published but that "theme" is not maintained. At one point, there are three strips on one page that are obviously part of a single narrative but the last strip on the page is the "setup" for the punchlines in the first two. This was only the most glaring example of the lack of effort put into this book. Several other related strips appear out of order (in at least one case, separated by about 1/3rd of the book). Other strips are presented without critical context (presumably because the contextual strips don't feature Wally?) so they lose a lot of their punch.
I laughed while reading the book but I couldn't help imagining the publisher was also laughing on his way to the bank with my money.
REVIEW Apr 16, 2007
I am a big fan of DILBERT, and I'm sure that you will think this book is hilarious. Wally is probably my favorite character, and Dilbert is my second. Office politics are so funny, and Scot Adams hits them on top of the head.
|
| | |
|
|
|
|
|
